Trip Prep
Is That Cruise Package Actually Worth It? Our New Calculators Do the Math for You
You know the moment. You've picked the ship, found the cabin, and you're one click from booking when the screen offers you one more thing: a package with drinks, Wi-Fi, a dinner or two, maybe some excursion credit, all for "just" $65 a day.
It sounds like a bargain. It might be. But "per person, per day" has a sneaky way of turning into $900 for a week-long sailing for two, and the cruise lines know most of us will never sit down with a spreadsheet to check.
So we built the spreadsheet for you. Meet the Cruise Concierge Pro Cruise Package Calculators: free, quick, and brutally honest about whether a package will save you money or quietly take it.
Five Packages, Four Cruise Lines, One Honest Answer
We started with the packages our travelers ask about most. Each one gets its own calculator, built around that cruise line's actual rules and current published U.S. prices:
| Calculator | The question it answers | The surprise it uncovers |
|---|---|---|
| Holland America Have It All | Is the bundle of drinks, Wi-Fi, dining, excursion credit and crew appreciation worth the daily price? | At $65 a day, it costs less than the Signature Beverage Package bought on its own ($71.92 a day with service). |
| Princess Plus | Do drinks, Wi-Fi, gratuities and casual dining add up to more than $70 a day? | Crew appreciation alone covers $18 of that price before you order a single drink. |
| Celebrity All Included | Should you book the All Included fare or the cruise-only fare? | Despite the name, staff gratuities aren't included. You pay them with either fare. |
| NCL Free at Sea | Are the Open Bar and specialty dining worth their charges? | "Free" comes with a $28.50-a-day Open Bar charge and $20 per specialty meal, and you can decline either one. |
| NCL Free at Sea Plus | Is the $49.99-a-day upgrade worth it on top of Free at Sea? | Prepaid service charges cover $20 of it, so the real question is whether the rest is worth $29.99. |
How It Works (Spoiler: It Doesn't Flatter the Package)
Cruise line "value" math usually assumes you'll use every perk at full onboard price. That's how a package gets advertised as "$2,000 in value." Our calculators assume something radical: you are a real person with real habits.
You tell us how many cocktails, coffees and sodas you'd actually order, whether you'd buy Wi-Fi anyway, which specialty dinners you'd really book, and what you'd spend on excursions. Then every perk is valued at what it would honestly cost you without the package:
- Unused perks count as $0. A $100 excursion credit is worth nothing if you'd rather explore the port on foot.
- Drinks are capped at reality. If you drink enough to justify the line's standalone drink package, that package price is the most the drinks are worth, because that's what you'd have bought instead.
- Drink price limits are respected. If a package only covers drinks up to $12 or $15, a pricier cocktail only counts up to that limit, since you'd pay the difference either way.
- The rules are built in. Excursion credit and dining nights that grow with cruise length, "first two guests only" rules, Grand Voyage and Galápagos exclusions, suite gratuity rates: the calculator handles them so you don't have to read the fine print at midnight.
Then you get a clear verdict (Worth it, Close call or Skip it), the dollar difference for your whole sailing, a breakdown of where the value comes from, and your break-even point: the number of drinks a day it takes for the package to pay for itself.
Same Cabin, Two Very Different Answers
Here's why we built these instead of just telling everyone to "always get the package." Take a couple on a 7-day Holland America cruise, looking at Have It All at $65 per person per day: $910 for the week.
Couple #1: The Sunset Cocktail Crew
Three drinks a day each, a couple of cappuccinos, one of them wants Wi-Fi, and they'll use their excursion credit and specialty dinner. Verdict: Worth it. Have It All saves them about $439 over the week. Their break-even is less than one drink a day.
Couple #2: The Early-to-Bed Explorers
Same ship, same cabin, same price. But they don't drink alcohol, they're happy to unplug, and they'd rather wander the port than book a tour. Verdict: Skip it. Paying as they go saves them about $433.
Same package. A swing of nearly $900. That's not a rounding error. That's a couple of shore excursions, a spa day, or a very nice dinner in port.
The Norwegian Twist: Keep What Pays, Decline What Doesn't
Norwegian's Free at Sea works differently, so its calculator does too. Because you can turn down the Open Bar and specialty dining separately, it scores each perk on its own.
A light drinker on a 7-night sailing might see "Keep the dining only." The Open Bar would cost two guests $399 in charges for about $260 of drinks, but three specialty dinners each are worth $300 against just $120 in service charges. Keeping only the dining saves about $180. Taking "free" everything would have thrown most of that away.
Tips for the Most Accurate Answer
- Use the prices on your quote. Package prices change, and Celebrity prices All Included by sailing. Every price field can be edited, so plug in your real numbers.
- Be honest about drinks. Count what you'd order at full price, not what you'd drink because it's "free." Package math has fooled a lot of people, and the second mai tai has fooled even more.
- Think about the whole cabin. Most lines require everyone in the stateroom to buy the same drink package or fare. One light drinker can sink the math for two.
- Watch the break-even line. If you're within a drink a day of it, you're in "Close call" territory. Then the tiebreaker is personal: do you love having everything prepaid, or do you love flexibility more?
More Calculators on the Way
These five are just the first wave. We're adding more cruise lines and packages as they change, and we update the prices whenever the cruise lines do. Sailing a line we don't cover yet? Tell us, and it might be next.
Let a Concierge Run the Real Numbers
The calculators give you a fast, honest answer. A concierge gives you the full picture: what your loyalty status already includes, which promotions stack, when a package goes on sale, and whether a different cabin or sailing would make the whole question disappear.
Run your numbers at cruiseconciergepro.com/calculators, then send your results to chip@cruiseconciergepro.com. Chip will price your sailing both ways and make sure every perk you've earned is working for you.
Fair winds and following seas,
The Cruise Concierge Pro Team